Age Discrimination: 5 Steps To Knowing When An Employee Is Unfairly Dismissed By Way Of "Retirement"

The Employment Equality (Age) Regulations 2006 - SI No 2006/1031 - came into force on 1 October 2006 to protect employees from being dismissed unfairly by reason of their age. The Age Regulations make it unlawful to discriminate against employees, job seekers and trainees because of their age both old and young. The protection covers direct and indirect discrimination, harassment and victimization. Employers and employees alike must familiarise themselves with these far reaching changes.

This article addresses:

(1) the particular unfairness of early retirement which essentially involves retirement ages being arbitrarily fixed below 65 without justification; and

(2) the requirement for a fair procedure to be followed in all retirement dismissals. Section 98 of the Employment Rights Act 1996 is amended to include a new potentially fair reason for dismissal - that of retirement. As with other reasons for dismissal, it remains the case that the employer must "show" any Employment Tribunal what the reason for dismissal is.

If the employer wishes to be able to rely on retirement as a reason for dismissal, the chances of successfully doing so are greatly increased if he follows the procedures set out in the Age Regulations. That is to say that at least 6 months prior to the dismissal (but no more than a year prior to the dismissal) he notifies the employee of the date on which he intends that the employee should retire and he informs the employee that the employee has a right to request to work beyond retirement age. This is known as the 6 month rule.

The Age Regulations remove the upper age limit for claiming unfair dismissal and redundancy and give older workers the same rights to claim unfair dismissal or receive a redundancy payment as younger workers, unless there is a genuine retirement.

Where Retirement Dismissal Is Unfair

There are 5 circumstances where genuine retirement cannot be the reason for dismissal no matter what the employer argues in an Employment Tribunal and where dismissal will therefore be unfair. Those 5 circumstances of unfair dismissal are:

No Fixed Retirement Ages Specified

(1) The employee has no fixed retirement age, but the dismissal takes effect before the employee reaches the age of 65. The default retirement age in the absence of one having been specified is now 65. It should be noted, however, that an employer will not be able to rely on the default retirement age of 65 to retire employees earlier than he would otherwise, for example if the employees retirement aged had previously been set at 68.

Fixed Retirement Ages Specified

(2) The employer has a fixed retirement age which is below the age of 65, the dismissal takes effect after that age, but the reduced retirement age is not objectively justified. This means that the employer has to establish what objective and proportionate reason exists to warrant a lower retirement age. This will be rare.

(3) The employee has a fixed retirement age whether above or below 65, but the employee is dismissed for retirement before the employee reaches that previously fixed age.

6 Months Notice Rule

(4) The employee has a fixed retirement age over the age of 65, the employer gives notice to dismiss within the 6 months rule, but the dismissal takes effect before the intended date of retirement date so notified.

(5) The employer does not notify the employee in accordance with the 6 months rule, but he does notify the employee of an intended date of retirement, but the dismissal takes effect before that intended date of retirement.

Right to work beyond the intended retirement date

If the employee indicates his wish to exercise his right to request working beyond the intended retirement date the employer must arrange a meeting. If the employer has notified in accordance with the 6 months rule, the request must be made at least 3 months but not more than 6 months before the intended date of retirement. If the employer has failed to notify in accordance with the 6 months rule, the request can be made at any time within the six month period before the intended date of retirement.

The employer must hold a meeting with the employee within a reasonable period after receiving the request unless, during that period, the employer and employee agree that the employee is to retire later or it is not practicable to hold a meeting within the period. If it is not practicable to hold a meeting within the period the employer must still consider the request.

Copyright 2006 Ian Mann

Ian Mann is an Employment Barrister at 13 Kings Bench Walk, Temple, London and was called to the Bar in 2000. He practices in employment disputes representing both employers and employees. His employment practice embraces the full spectrum of Employment Tribunal, High Court and appellate work and covers all areas of employment law, especially discrimination. See his website at http://www.employment-barrister-uk.com

Retirement Planning
Once a person reaches a certain age or acquires a certain amount of work experience, he becomes eligible for retirement. Every organization should have clear-cut rules regarding retirement and it should help the employees in adjusting themselves after retirement to the new realities of life. Some organizations provide pensions for their retired emp...

Public Employees Retirement System
For every employee who has worked for years, retirement is something they enthusiastically look forward to. The vision of just being relaxed throughout the day, doing things at their own way and at their own pace, is a feeling of complete satisfaction after long years of commitment to work. Its finally time to reap the fruits of hard work, whether...

Employee Retirement Income Security Act
The Employee Retirement Income Security Act (ERISA) of 1974, is a United States federal law ratified to guard interstate commerce and the interests of members in employee benefit plans and their beneficiaries, through necessitating the reporting and disclosure to participants and beneficiaries of financial and other information with respect thereto...

Retirement Plans
Retirement is one of lifes biggest worries and retirement plans play a crucial role in providing a source of income in a persons retired years. Retirement can span up to a third of a lifetime. Retirement plans are much like saving for a 25-year vacation. To afford an expense of that magnitude a person needs to start planning early. Age has a critic...

Cash Balance Plans: The Next Great Retirement Plan for Small Business Owners
When you think of cash balance pension plans you tend to think of IBM and other large companies that have used them to reduce their employee benefit costs. What many people do not realize is that in the right situation, these plans can provide a number of benefits to small business owners as well.Traditionally, when a small business owner wanted t...

The Golden Years: Planning for Retirement
It is easy for an adult to ask a child what they want to do when they grow up. There are limitless possibilities available to them. When you grow older, this question should still be asked, even beyond the work force.There are several different things that should be considered for you to fully enjoy the later years of your life. If you want to do e...

Employee Retirement Plans For Small Businesses
Buying Employee Retirement Plans for Small Businesses has two advantages, tax-advantage for the owner as well as being much appreciated benefit to the employees. There are several plans to choose from and the owner has to seek expert guidance to select the best-suited plan or combination of plans. They have to analyze which plan best suits the busi...